I think I’ve sent my last fact checking article. I’ve gotten so used to investigating suspicious links on Snopes and sending rebuttals, to copying and pasting Politifact URLs into messages, that I have failed to notice the utter uselessness of those activities. I keep sending them to the same people.

The facetious promise of fact checking is that liars will be held to account and forced, by a truth-demanding public, to reign in exaggerations and to tighten up misleading claims. And that seems to work often enough. But the bald-faced lie, the pants-on-fire falsehood, actually seems impervious to fact checking in a way that spin is not. And I don’t know what to do with that.

Our discourse if now filled with claims and official statements that nobody defends as true. The inauguration crowd was not the largest ever. “Under God” was not omitted from the Pledge of Allegiance. The map was clearly altered with a Sharpie, for heaven’s sake. Exposing the falsehood of these assertions is easy, and it is useless.

Lies like these are a weapon against which fact checking is defenseless. Because they are not actually attempts to establish an actual state of affairs or even to spin a narrative. They are assertions of power. The ability to contradict reality in broad daylight and to be lauded for it is a fearsome ability. It means that people fear to contradict you. Lies and fear go hand-in-hand.

What’s the alternative to fact checking? Building honest power honestly. When we use our influence to advance transparency and integrity, we strike a greater blow against falsehood than a lifetime of fact checking.

5 thoughts on “Lies

  1. Thank you for stating such a clear alternative to the lies and fear. It reminds me of the times people have asked me where I earned my master’s degree — and the look on their faces when I say that I have never started one. (Who can pick a subject? I can’t.) Show intelligence and integrity, then let people wonder where it’s from. Bob Woodward’s book about the present White House said it all in the title: FEAR.

  2. I look into the eyes of some of those whom I love and my heart breaks that they have given in to the fear that has been propagated. They are so fully invested in the lies being spewed to the point our relationships are disintegrating before my eyes. I want these relationships to heal but I don’t know how possible that is anymore. The stances we take right now and the choices we make in 65 days are crucially tied to my mental well being so I can imagine it is the same for those whom I love on “the other side.” How is that going to play out?

  3. The lies are coming from both sides. I’ve had to just not talk politics with family and friends who don’t believe as I do. I think they’ve drunk the Kool aid for the side they like and they think the same about me. Better to not discuss it.

  4. Pingback: Fact | YoRocko!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s